Marsy's Law

Marsy's Law

HARRISBURG – A divided Supreme Court declined to intervene to lift an injunction barring the state from certifying the votes cast on a ballot question about adding a Victim’s Bill of Rights to the state Constitution until after a legal challenge is resolved.

While the results won’t be official, pending the resolution of that legal challenge, the Department of State plans to reveal the unofficial vote tally for the proposal to add a Victim’s Bill of Rights to the state Constitution, an agency spokeswoman said Monday.

The question is on the ballot today.

The Victim’s Bill of Rights proposed in Marsy’s Law has been challenged by the League of Women Voters and the American Civil Liberties Union over concerns that the public should allowed to vote for the proposed reforms separately rather than all together.

Commonwealth Court Judge Ellen Ceisler last Wednesday sided with the League of Women Voters and the ACLU, finding that their challenge had a good chance of being successful. Attorney General Josh Shapiro appealed to the state Supreme Court to overrule Ceisler, but the justices on Monday issued an order siding with the lower court judge.

Chief Justice Thomas Saylor wrote a dissenting opinion which said that Ceisler’s move to bar counting the votes “has significant potential to foster uncertainty amongst the electorate, and therefore, to impact upon the election’s outcome.”

Justices Kevin Dougherty and Sallie Mundy joined Saylor’s dissent.

The majority of the Supreme Court, however, concluded that Ceisler’s injunction would not deprive anyone of the right to vote.

The Supreme Court decision was “a win for voters,” said Reggie Shuford, executive director of the ACLU of Pennsylvania. “The General Assembly gave voters an overwhelming ballot question and forced them to vote up or down on the entire package. There may be provisions of Marsy’s Law that a voter likes and provisions they don’t like, but they have no opportunity to vote individually on each piece. The legislature forced them into an unfair, take-it-or-leave-it choice.”

Jennifer Riley, state director for the Marsy’s Law campaign in Pennsylvania, called Ceisler’s injunction “unprecedented and extreme” and added that proponents are disappointed by the Supreme Court’s decision to uphold Ceisler’s order. “We remain confident that the Supreme Court will ultimately rule in favor of certifying the election results,” Riley said. “We believe that we have the stronger legal case, backed by bipartisan support of elected representatives in the legislature. It is now more important than ever that Pennsylvanians get to the polls and vote for Marsy’s Law.”

The effort to enshrine the rights of victims in the state Constitution is part of a Marsy’s Law national campaign launched by billionaire Henry Nicholas after the 1983 murder of his sister, Marsalee Nicholas.

The Victim's Bill of Rights proposed in Marsy’s Law would mandate that victims receive notice about court hearings and the release or escape of the accused, protection from the accused, prompt conclusion to the prosecution of the case and the right to confer with prosecutors, according to a summary of the law prepared by legislative staff.

Wanda Murren, a Department of State spokeswoman, said despite the court order, state officials plan to post the unofficial results on the state’s election returns web site Tuesday night.

County election officials have been told to handle the results from the ballot question the same way they handle the rest of Tuesday’s results, Murren said.

“The counties have been told they do not have to do anything differently than they usually do,” Murren said. “They are to follow all normal election procedures, so it is likely that most, if not all, of them will have the ballot question numbers reported on their websites.”

Murren said the Department of State is reminding voters to answer the ballot question even if the votes aren’t going to immediately count, because it is possible that the courts could conclude that the vote should be certified.

CNHI PA State Reporter

CNHI State Reporter John Finnerty covers the Pennsylvania Statehouse for CNHI's newspapers and websites. Follow him on Twitter @cnhipa. Email him at

Recommended for you

(0) comments

Welcome to the discussion.

Keep it Clean. Please avoid obscene, vulgar, lewd, racist or sexually-oriented language.
Don't Threaten. Threats of harming another person will not be tolerated.
Be Truthful. Don't knowingly lie about anyone or anything.
Be Nice. No racism, sexism or any sort of -ism that is degrading to another person.
Be Proactive. Use the 'Report' link on each comment to let us know of abusive posts.
Share with Us. We'd love to hear eyewitness accounts, the history behind an article.