NEW CASTLE —
(Last of three parts)
Nationally and locally, the economy was taking some hits in the early and late 1980s.
Before the decade was three years old, both Johnson Bronze and Mesta Machine shut down their New Castle plants. Recession returned in the late 1980s, and in 1991, Shenango China closed for good. Two years later, the end came for Rockwell.
Throughout it all, the Towne Mall soldiered on, but time was running out.
“That probably played a role,” Jack Haims, owner of The Clothes Post (later The Ladies Store) said of the industrial closings. “Every little thing helps. But I can remember what was happening downtown, even before the mall. It was all the offices moving.
“Liberty Mutual was downtown at one time, and they moved to Wilmington Road. Bell Telephone switched to machines, and they don’t shop on their lunch hour. All those types of things would have an effect on it.”
Indeed, other former Towne Mall merchants agree, it may have been relocations rather than closings that spelled the end for the mall.
Prime among those departures was Sears, which left its anchor spot and reopened on Oct. 26, 1996, in Union Township. That followed the mid-1980s departure of Giant Eagle, which had a supermarket on the mall property. It now operates stores on Butler and Wilmington roads.
“That was the third-best Giant Eagle in the state of Pennsylvania,” recalled Mr. Pizza owner Rich Guadagno. “When it went out, and Sears and Murphy’s went out, those were anchor stores. Once the anchors go, it doesn’t bring in people any more.”
John Yergan, owner of the New Castle Hobby Center, agreed.
“When the big grocery store moved out, that was sort of the beginning of the end,” he said. “Then Sears pulled out, and that was a tremendous blow. Little by little, businesses started closing. We saw the decline over the years, reaching the point where we were actually supporting our business out of our pocket, and we couldn’t keep that up.
“We were there, probably, until we were down to about five stores, but July 31, 1997, was our last day.”
Vivian Sansone recalled that she and her husband, Tom, also stuck it out as long as possible in The Gift Gallery.
“We were there almost 30 years,” she said. “Once Sears and Murphy’s left, everything kind of went downhill. We were one of the last stores to close. He wanted to stick it out because he kept thinking it was going to come back.
“It was sad. He didn’t want to give it up, but finally, we just had to.”
According to county records, mall ownership changed hands four times between 1987 and 1996, starting with a sale by original owner John Blackson of Arcon Development. Guadagno believes Blackson’s health was in decline at the time.
The mall was purchased from Blackson by Mark Scharfman, owner of a New York City-based real estate firm. However, it went on to be sold at sheriff’s sale just three years later, when it was picked up by Union National Bank of Pittsburgh. The bank, in turn, sold it to PES Inc., a group of Cleveland-based investors, on July 23, 1991.
Finally, New Castle developer Thomas George and partner Robert Bruce bought the mall at auction in Cleveland on Dec. 6, 1995. The sale was finalized two months later.
The new owners also changed the name of the mall to Cascade Galleria.
“Tom George saw the declining situation, and he really worked to give us a break, rent-wise,” Yergan said. “He really did his best to keep us there. It just came to the place where we couldn’t do it any longer.”
Indeed, just days before the auction, two longtime mall tenants — the Health Hut and the Sweet Shoppe, now owned by Felicia Caizza Francisco — announced they’d be pulling out and relocating in Union Township. Health Hut manager Don Hardesty told The News at the time that the mall “is not drawing enough traffic,” while Francisco noted that “the mall has been in upheaval. It’s lost its appeal.”
Mall merchants not only were on their fourth landlord in nine years, but also dealing with growing community sentiment that safety there was not what it should be.
Just before finalizing his purchase, George told The News that his first campaign would be to disprove that notion.
“The mall has gotten a bad rap,” he said. “It’s extremely exaggagerated.”
Whatever had begun to eat away at the foundation of the Towne Mall’s retail kingdom — the economy, relocations, changes in ownership, safety issues — it could not be stopped.
Now, the once-teeming shopping center houses such tenants as the New Castle campus of the Erie Business Center (in what had been Sears), an AT&T Relay Center (Murphy’s), the Department of Public Assistance (Thrift Drug, Richman Brothers), Shenango China Area Federal Credit Union (Gift Gallery), Adagio (which recently moved from what had been People’s Bank into what formerly was Sears Auto Center) and the Department of Workmen’s Compensation Office of Adjudication (Musicland, Sears Cafeteria).
A smattering of retail remains in Dollar General and Fastenal, also occupying sections of the former Sears store, as do an Internet cafe and a dialysis center. There’s also a post office branch, as well as original tenant Towne Mall Beauty Salon and a pizza shop — Town Mall Pizza — in the same location as the former Mr. Pizza.
Beer 4 Less occupies the store where Giant Eagle once did business.
From time to time, some of the mall’s former merchants will head to Cascade Galleria to reminisce.
“It’s heartbreaking to see what’s happened to it,” Yergan said. “I remember the Christmas shopping season there, for a span of 10 or 15 years, it was just phenomenal. The number of people — you had to elbow your way through the crowd.”
“I walked around once,” Sweet Shoppe owner Irene Downing added. “It makes you kind of melancholy.”
“Occasionally I go down there,” Clothes Post/Ladies Store owner Jack Haims allows. “They cut it up a little bit, but my room’s still there. It was a nice store; we had a good time there.”
One person who avoids the mall’s memory lane is Gift Gallery owner Vivian Sansone.
“I’ve gone down to the post office, but that’s about as far as I go,” she said. “I don’t think I’ve ever walked past our old store.
“It would be hard. I wouldn’t like that.”
Now, it’s your turn: Share your favorite Towne Mall memories and we’ll run them in our July 4 edition. Email them with your name and address to email@example.com. We’re looking forward to hearing from you!)
NEW CASTLE —
(Last of three parts)
- TOP STORIES
Suspect’s death from ‘natural causes’
The suspect who died one year to the day after running over two boys — killing one — died of natural causes. A toxicology report on Virgil E. Coonfare, 67, of Lawrence Manor, was ordered by the coroner. It revealed nothing out of the ordinary.
Test-driven: Changes in GED exam take effect Jan. 2
For some people, a GED is one of the most important pieces of paper they may possess. And achieving that accomplishment could be a resolution for the new year. Ashley Leonard had a goal to pass her GED and once she did, new doors opened up almost immediately.
Photos, Video, Story: Shenango homecoming queen Brittany Chieze considers herself ‘a pretty lucky girl’
Rochelle Chieze admits she panicked at first when she learned her daughter had been placed on Shenango High’s Homecoming ballot. “I started thinking about the germs from being around so many people and how tired this would make her,” Rochelle said. “Even though she was thrilled — we all were — I went back and forth. I thought maybe we should say no.”
Neshannock school board told to follow the rules
In her first meeting as president, Karen Houk established procedures for the Neshannock Township School Board. This chain of command, Houk said, will ensure that everyone in the district is treated equally.
Neshannock proposes budget with no tax hike
The Neshannock Township supervisors introduced a budget with no tax increase or sewer rate hike. The document, introduced Friday, will be on display at the municipal building for 20 days. The supervisors plan to vote on the spending plan at a special meeting set for 9 a.m. Dec. 30.
Neshannock superintendent Dr. Mary Todora to retire
Dr. Mary Todora, Neshannock’s superintendent, will retire at the end of this school year. The board voted 6-3 Thursday night to accept Todora’s resignation, effective June 30.
Shop with a Cop makes 116 children happy
All Mason Work wanted for Christmas was a basketball. But when the 8-year-old New Castle boy left Walmart Thursday, he was the excited owner of a new scooter, a toy equalizer gun and a pair of Spiderman boots, in addition to a blue and white Wilson basketball.
Councilman thinks house purchase an ‘illegal act by the mayor’
New Castle Councilman William Panella believes the mayor committed an act of malfeasance in buying a property without council’s approval. “I think it’s an illegal act by the mayor,” Panella said at Tuesday’s work session regarding the purchase of a property at 315 E. Hillcrest Ave.
County’s borrowing will merge debts
The Lawrence County commissioners are consolidating the county’s debts for more efficient and cost-effective operations.
Shenango considering sewer sale
Shenango Township is trying to decide whether to sell its sewer system. A recent public meeting on the matter drew only about 15 residents and the Shenango supervisors said they will schedule another meeting to get more input.
- More TOP STORIES Headlines
- Suspect’s death from ‘natural causes’