New Castle News


June 13, 2014

Attorney: Solicitor violated Sunshine Act

NEW CASTLE — A Pennsylvania NewsMedia Association lawyer said Mahoning Township’s solicitor violated state law by forbidding recording at a hearing this week.

Attorney Louis Perrotta conducted a conditional use zoning hearing before township supervisors for wellpads and a compressor station Tuesday and told the audience to turn off any recording devices.

Melissa Melewsky, media law counsel for the organization, said, “There is no case law on it, but the language of the Sunshine Act is clear.” At township meetings, she said, “anyone attending has the right to record.”

When local agencies act in a “quasi-judicial manner,” she explained, “they do not become courts/judges and they are not subject to the rules of judicial administration, such as rules that prohibit recording in a courtroom.”

Melewsky explained local elected officials “do not become judges when they decide issues in a quasi-judicial manner; they are township supervisors exercising a fact-finding role pursuant to statute.”

She concluded that while the Sunshine Act allows them to deliberate privately, “... the hearing itself is required to be public and accessible, including the right to record.”

Perrotta disagrees.

“At no time did I say you could not videotape the proceedings. They were free to do what they wanted. I didn’t take away anyone’s device.”

He explained Thursday he personally did not want to be recorded.

He read the following transcript of his statement: “ I do not consent to be videotaped, either visually or audibly. So if you have a camera this evening and if you are videotaping me, please stop or I’m going to turn you over for prosecution and you will also be subject to civil liability.”

Further on in the meeting, Perrotta said that when he saw a woman recording him, he said that if she was doing so, “I ask you to shut it off.”

He said at that time, Police Chief Jim Morris asked another person to turn off a recording device.

Perrotta noted he thinks he said at that time, “I’m not going to waste time arguing with people.”

Melewsky said it doesn’t matter and “I respectfully disagree with that attorney’s opinion.”

She said Perrotta is “talking about a wiretap violation,” explaining consent is needed to record someone “where there is a reasonable expectation of privacy.”

But she said there is no such expectation at a public meeting.

Pursuant to the state Sunshine Act, she said, those who record a public meeting “are exercising a guaranteed right.”

Melewsky said any member of the public could request an injunction against the township to prevent it from doing this again.

The township supervisors also could be charged with a summary offense in criminal court if they “knowingly” violated the Sunshine Act, she said, but added if the solicitor made the statements to the public, it is unlikely the supervisors knowingly violated it.

Perrotta also commented that section 710.1 of the Sunshine Act speaks to public participation and has a provision stating the taxpayers of a jurisdiction have the ability to comment.

He added Section 711, governing recording devices, is subject to enforcing rules under 710.1. He said he does not believe any of those who had been recording the hearing are township residents.

A similar situation occurred this week in Neshannock Township.

Those supervisors were considering a request to construct a wellpad on King’s Chapel Road.

At the start of the hearing, Perrotta, who also is Neshannock’s solicitor, requested that several women in the audience not tape the proceedings.

“I do not consent to be recorded,” he said.

Several of the women used their cellphones to record Perrotta, the supervisors and representatives of Hilcorp during the hearing.

(Reporter Nancy Lowry contributed to this story.)


Text Only | Photo Reprints
  • DougDanko.jpg Census shows county population getting older

    Lawrence County’s population continues to get older. However, it is not alone, as Pennsylvania overall is aging.

    July 30, 2014 1 Photo

  • backpackproject.jpg Councilman picks up tab to help lunch program

    Participants of a local summer feeding program are eating this week courtesy of New Castle City Councilman Tim Fulkerson. On Friday morning, the truck dispatched from New Castle to pick up about 3,500 pounds of items from the Pittsburgh Food Bank broke down as it arrived at its destination.

    July 28, 2014 1 Photo

  • CRESTVIEW.jpg Outreach: Churches plan to host picnic for residents of Crestview Gardens

    Volunteers from several area churches are banding together in hopes of bringing peace to a troubled neighborhood.

    July 28, 2014 1 Photo

  • money.jpg Council OKs funds to remove dead trees

    New Castle City Council has approved spending funds from its contingency account to remove some trees at Darlington Park. Marshall Tree Experts of Ellwood City has given an estimate of $12,000 to remove the large elm trees from the Mahoningtown park.


    July 26, 2014 1 Photo

  • 12.jpg Photo Gallery, Story: Night light

    The balloons may have been on the ground but spirits were soaring.


    July 25, 2014 1 Photo 1 Slideshow

  • StateFair.jpg 'State Fair' coming to Playhouse

    The fair is coming to town. No, not the Lawrence County Fair, although that is right around the corner. This is the Iowa State Fair, and it will be live on the stage of the New Castle Playhouse for three weeks, starting Friday night.

    July 24, 2014 1 Photo

  • accountant.jpg DeLorenzo’s status with authority unchanged

    Deno DeLorenzo’s status as a contract employee with the New Castle Sanitation Authority remains unchanged. Authority board members met with DeLorenzo last week regarding an investigation by the Lawrence County district attorney’s office involving Shenango Township funds.

    July 23, 2014 1 Photo

  • Shooting.jpg Detroit area man dies in Ellwood City gunfire

    A triple shooting in an Ellwood City street has claimed the life of a Detroit area man. Gunfire erupted in the middle of Loop Street outside the Walnut Ridge housing project around 10:20 p.m. Sunday, according to state police.

    July 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • Baptism1.jpg Dipped downtown

    John the Baptist identified himself as “the voice of one crying in the wilderness, ‘Make straight the way of the Lord.’ ” On Saturday, local evangelist Randy Crum once again took a cue from the son of Elizabeth and Zechariah, eschewing the locusts and honey that John was known to munch on but heading out into the wilds to baptize believers and challenge them to share their faith with their community.

    July 21, 2014 3 Photos

  • lamancusa.jpg Tanner, district attorney: No comment

    The Lawrence County District Attorney is keeping mum about a probe into finances in Shenango Township. “We don’t talk about ongoing investigations,” Lamancusa said Friday.

    July 19, 2014 1 Photo 5 Stories

House Ads

Do you talk to yourself when you're alone?

Yes, but I’m basically just thinking out loud.
No, that would be weird.
I don’t know. Next time I’m alone, I’ll ask.
     View Results