New Castle News

News Bloggers

December 12, 2013

Tim Kolodziej: Despite critics, Carrie Underwood taught us plenty in the ‘Sound of Music’

NEW CASTLE — We love.

To hate.

Don’t believe me? Just take a ride through the social media strata on any given evening — especially when a big event is going down.

It’s disheartening. It really is.

Everyone’s an expert.

Everyone’s a critic.

Everyone’s a comedian.

We don’t just sling mud. We’re chucking sticks, stones and whatever else we can get our hands on.

We love.

To hate.

We just do.

It was me. I’ll admit it.

I was the viewer who put the “Sound of Music” television special over 18.5 million last Thursday night.

It’s the first time — that I can remember, anyway — I’ve watched the production all the way through.

Go ahead and pull my “man card,” but I tuned in for three reasons:

1) I thought it would be a fun holiday night of viewing for our family. My wife has seen the movie several times and loves it.

2) I was intrigued by the concept of a live performance on TV.

3) I like Carrie Underwood.

And you know what, it WAS a fun night of viewing.

I REALLY enjoyed the live special.

And I STILL like Carrie Underwood.

Yep, I’m THAT viewer, too.

Underwood is not a Broadway actress — she’s a singer by trade. Through determination, talent and hard work, she rose to prominence a few years back by winning her season of “American Idol.”

So, as you might expect, her performance as Maria Von Trapp was absolutely crushed on Twitter throughout the three-hour special. This tweet pretty much sums it up: “Jesus take the role ... from Carrie Underwood.”

News reports this week revealed she even received hate mail at home.



But she had company wearing a target on her back. Last week, Underwood was no different than Mike Tomlin, Sarah Palin, the Ohio State football team or anyone else who dared enter the arena.

Battered. Bruised. Blistered. Torched.

We could argue that the 24-hour cable news channels have turned our society into a raging army of talking heads. To a certain extent, that’s probably true. One of the most dangerous questions you could ask these days is, “What do you think about ...?”

But psychologist Philip Cushman has a theory called “The Empty Self,” which offers another glimpse at human behavior. According to Cushman, the empty self seeks to be made happy by food, entertainment, and other consumer goods.

In his book, “Limitless Life,” Derwin Gray shines a spotlight on the subject.

“People with the empty self are fixed on living their lives through the risks, challenges and adventures of OTHERS,” Gray writes. “The empty self is passive in the sense that he or she would rather do nothing and let life zip right by than to actually participate in life in a meaningful way.”

Have we become a bunch of empty selves? Would we rather just watch than do?

Maybe. If we just watch, make snarky remarks and criticize, we’re never wrong.


That’s pretty appealing to a lot of people.

Text Only | Photo Reprints
News Bloggers
House Ads

The film "Into the Storm," about a devastating tornado, opens nationally Aug. 1. What's your favorite storm movie?

The Day After Tomorrow
The Perfect Storm
     View Results