New Castle News


February 14, 2014

Our Opinion: Action needed to prevent taxpayer losses at Sylvan Heights

NEW CASTLE — Should New Castle taxpayers subsidize the operations of Sylvan Heights Golf Course?

Our answer is a flat-out, simple no.

Golf is not an essential city service. And while the case can be made municipalities ought to provide recreation facilities for young people — such as basketball and tennis courts — a golf course does not fit into that category.

For one thing, golf is generally not a kid’s game. We think it’s safe to say the vast majority of Sylvan Heights users are adults.

And — to be blunt about it — golf is not an activity that’s generally enjoyed by folks on the lower end of the economic spectrum. It takes money to play golf, whether the course is publicly or privately owned.

We bring all this up because it was reported this week that Sylvan Heights, the city-owned golf course located in Shenango Township, lost $25,000 last year. That’s money that had to be covered by New Castle’s general fund — another way of saying taxpayers had to pick up the tab to help people play golf.

The loss follows several years where the course was running close to even on its budget. Prior to that, a string of annual losses was halted after it was discovered a former employee had been stealing from the course.

At that time, there were discussions about privatizing the course in some fashion. Apparently, deed restrictions prevent the city from selling the course outright, but it still has the option of turning it over to a private operator for management.

If that were to occur, it would be up to the operator to make sure all costs were covered. The city could even demand revenue from the course as part of the agreement.

Of course, some person or entity would have to be willing to shoulder the risk in these circumstances. Perhaps there would be no takers to such a proposal.

But under the circumstances, the city needs to explore its options. A financially distressed community cannot afford to lose money on a golf course.

We recognize that privatization is more complex than it sounds. Any agreement would have to protect the city from liability regarding actions not under its control. There also would have to be requirements that the private management entity maintains the course and structures. The last thing the city needs is a firm coming in and draining the course of money without making the necessary investments.

Regardless, taxpayers should not put money into Sylvan Heights. The city should increase fees or make other changes before dipping into the general fund to support the course. The red ink at Sylvan Heights must stop.

Text Only | Photo Reprints
  • Drake.tiff Athlete of the Week: Meet Hannah Drake of Wilmington

    Hannah Drake is a track and field coach’s dream. The Wilmington junior can step into virtually any event and score points for her team.

    April 16, 2014 1 Photo

  • Spring Sports: A roundup of action from April 14

    Miranda Schry and Nicole Watkins had big days yesterday. The Shenango High track standouts each posted three wins in a 99 1/2-49 1/2 victory over visiting Neshannock.

    April 16, 2014

  • Magliocca.tiff 2014 Hall of Fame Inductees: Today, meet Linda Magliocca

    This is the first in a series of feature stories on the 2014 inductees into the Lawrence County Historical Society Sports Hall of Fame.

    April 15, 2014 1 Photo

  • HOF.jpg Spring Sports: A roundup of action from April 14

    The Neshannock High baseball team passed a big test last night. The host Lancers answered a late Laurel surge with a single run in the sixth inning to escape with a 6-4 win in WPIAL Section 5-AA action.

    April 15, 2014 1 Photo

  • HOF.jpg Spring Sports: A roundup of action from April 12

    The Neshannock High softball team continued to roll Saturday. Madison Shaffer tossed a complete-game two-hit shutout to lift the Lady Lancers to a 6-0 WPIAL Section 4-A home win over Shenango.

    April 14, 2014 1 Photo

  • shen1.tiff Shenango baseball team knocks it out of the park with toy drive

    The Shenango High baseball team hit a home run with kids at Children’s Hospital. Led by Tyler Booher and Anthony Prestopine, the Wildcats spent the last two months conducting a toy drive to benefit the young patients of the Pittsburgh facility. They ended up with about 200 items.

    April 13, 2014 2 Photos

  • HOF.jpg Spring Sports: A roundup of action from April 11

    Neshannock High baseball pitcher Frank Fraschetti was dominant on the hill yesterday. Fraschetti limited Riverside to four hits in a complete-game 4-1 WPIAL Section 5-AA home win.

    April 12, 2014 1 Photo

  • HOF.jpg Spring Sports: A roundup of action from April 10

    The New Castle High baseball team found a way to pull out a win yesterday. The Red Hurricane scratched a run across in the bottom of the ninth to claim a 12-11 WPIAL Section 1-AAAA win over North Hills at Flaherty Field.

    April 11, 2014 1 Photo

  • Serg.tiff Athlete of the Week: Meet Neshannock’s Rich Serignese

    Rich Serignese is no stranger to pressure on the baseball field. The Neshannock High sophomore twice defeated WPIAL Class AA champion and PIAA runner-up Beaver a year ago, so facing a team that put up eye-popping numbers the night before was a piece of cake.

    April 10, 2014 1 Photo

  • HOF.jpg Spring Sports: A roundup of action from April 9

    Ellwood City Lincoln’s Dillon Horgan tossed a complete-game gem yesterday. Horgan scattered nine hits to lift the visiting Wolverines to a WPIAL Section 5-AA victory over Laurel, 6-2. Horgan (2-3) allowed two earned runs with three walks and six strikeouts to pick up the victory.

    April 10, 2014 1 Photo

AP BB Tourney Latest News2014
AP BB Tourney Poll 2014
House Ads
Shoot For 2
Photo of the Day