New Castle News


March 26, 2014

Our Opinion: Recording executive sessions will limit abuse

NEW CASTLE — Whenever governing bodies have public meetings, they often opt to conduct executive sessions.

This is perfectly legal under Pennsylvania law — so long as the basic purpose for the executive session is explained to the public and so long as officials refrain from discussing matters in private that are required to be addressed in the open.

But more than a few people left on the outside of executive sessions have wondered whether the matters being addressed behind closed doors were appropriate. And based on actions taken in public, there are — at times — nagging concerns that important public matters were resolved in private, rather than in the open light of day.

Pennsylvania’s Sunshine Law is supposedly designed to keep the people’s business out in the open. Yet it is subject to abuse, because there is no effective mechanism for determining whether executive sessions are limited to their expressed, authorized purposes.

But a bill introduced in the Pennsylvania House seeks to change that. It would require that executive sessions be recorded. If there was ever a challenge to actions related to these closed-door gatherings, the record could be reviewed by a court to ensure the law was followed.

Some local officials may object to such rules. But we believe the current Sunshine Law falls well short of the notion of public accountability. To be blunt, there are times when it appears some officials prefer to operate out of public view as much as possible. And it takes a toll on the trust people have in those who represent them.

Government isn’t supposed to work this way. The public’s business should be dealt with out in the open as much as possible. While executive sessions sometimes are necessary for personnel, litigation discussions, the handling of specific student matters and a few other limited areas, there is often a desire on the part of certain officials to interpret these exceptions as broadly as possible.

In representative government, it is essential that the public understands what government is doing in terms of public matters, so that the performance of elected officials can be properly assessed. When decisions are made in secret, how can citizens tell if the people they elected to office are performing effectively?

Unfortunately, Pennsylvania has a history of lack of openness at all levels of government. It’s a legacy that has bred corruption and abuse that continues to take its toll on the commonwealth.

Requiring the recording of executive sessions won’t eliminate corruption in Pennsylvania. But it will be a step toward the accountability that’s essential in keeping government clean.

Text Only | Photo Reprints
  • Yauger.jpg Yauger’s Mercer County trial on hold

    A pending criminal trial for the former Midwestern Intermediate Unit IV executive director has been continued again in Mercer County.

    July 9, 2014 1 Photo

  • Yauger.jpg Yauger now facing federal charge

    With Mercer County court proceedings pending this week, Cecelia Yauger faces federal prosecution for alleged business credit card misuse.

    July 8, 2014 1 Photo

  • school.jpg New Castle board adopts budget despite uncertainty

    The New Castle school board adopted its 2014-15 budget Monday but may have to re-open it next week. The $5.4 million budget, introduced in May, has no tax increase and will not tap into the fund balance. Taxes remain at 17.72 mills.

    July 2, 2014 1 Photo

  • Todora.jpg Board, staff bids farewell to superintendent

    Dr. Mary Todora will retire Monday from the Neshannock school district. “I remember eight and a half years ago when Dr. John Dietz (then-board president) called to tell me I got the job. I was thrilled,” Todora said at her final board meeting.

    June 26, 2014 1 Photo

  • Rich.jpg Vo-tech administrators get bonuses, no raises

    Lawrence County Career and Technical Center administrators will get one-time bonuses instead of raises next year. The joint operating committee approved one-year agreements that would freeze the salaries of director Leonard A. Rich and the principal, head custodian, cafeteria supervisor and computer technician.

    June 24, 2014 1 Photo

  • FrankAloi.jpg Frank Aloi: 50 years of school spirit in Ellwood City

    Frank Aloi is a true Wolverine. Aloi, who turned 73 Friday, spent the past half-century affiliated with the Ellwood City school district and its sports teams.

    June 22, 2014 2 Photos

  • FrankAloi.JPG Frank Aloi Retiring: Ellwood superintendent leaving amid budget woes

    Frank Aloi is retiring next month as Ellwood City’s superintendent of schools. Aloi, a 50-year district employee and its superintendent for nearly 12, submitted his retirement notice to the board during an executive session prior to Thursday’s meeting. His last day is July 16.

    June 17, 2014 1 Photo

  • school.jpg District mulls building sale options

    The New Castle school district is considering selling its three recently closed buildings through a sealed bid process.

    June 11, 2014 1 Photo

  • Perfect.jpg Your Education: Shenango grad never missed a day

    They say nobody’s perfect. But for 13 years, Jenna DiGiammarino certainly was. When Jenna left last night’s commencement ceremonies at Shenango High School, she did so not only with a diploma in hand, but also with a flawless record of attendance dating back to Day One of kindergarten.

    June 7, 2014 1 Photo

  • 03.jpg Photo Gallery, Story: Three New Castle schools close today for good

    Today is bittersweet for New Castle Area School District elementary students and teachers. Three buildings packed with history as longtime learning institutions are closing their doors for good.

    June 5, 2014 1 Photo

House Ads

The film "Into the Storm," about a devastating tornado, opens nationally Aug. 1. What's your favorite storm movie?

The Day After Tomorrow
The Perfect Storm
     View Results