New Castle News


April 15, 2014

Up through the ground comes education cash

NEW CASTLE — Democrats running for governor seem to be competing to convince voters they will dip deepest into the pockets of gas drillers to replace $1 billion that Gov. Tom Corbett has cut from education spending.

All four candidates running for the party’s nomination propose a severance tax on the value of natural gas pumped from each well. The candidates vary slightly in approach, but all say schools will be the beneficiary.

Pennsylvania now charges gas companies an impact fee — $50,000 per well in the first year, which diminishes until it expires 15 years later. The fee is roughly equivalent to a 2 percent severance tax, according to an Independent Fiscal Office report, which is far less than the Democratic candidates say it should be.

Corbett has steadfastly refused to support a severance tax, arguing it would slow the growth of the gas drilling industry.

“Governor Corbett has worked to ensure we are safely and responsibly using our natural resources to reduce energy prices for families and small businesses, grow our economy and create family-sustaining jobs,” said Corbett spokesman Billy Pitman. “Our liberal Democratic opponents have never seen a tax increase they didn’t like and continue to prove their misguided tax-and-spend policies are out of touch with Pennsylvanians.”

But Chris Borick, a political science professor at Muhlenberg College, said the Democrats’ push to link a drilling tax to education spending is an astute political move intended to capitalize on two of Corbett’s biggest weaknesses.

Polls show the public largely supports more school spending and blames Corbett for cutting education funds, he noted.

At the same time, while most Pennsylvanians support the gas industry, he said, there’s broad support for raising the extraction tax. The public generally doesn’t agree that it would drive away drillers, he added.

Most of the proposals floated by the Democratic candidates and lawmakers are in the range of a 5 percent severance tax, similar to West Virginia’s. The Pennsylvania Budget and Policy Center said the state would have generated another $300 million in revenue this year if drillers here had paid a tax at the West Virginia rate.

Treasurer Rob McCord’s plan would give Pennsylvania one of the highest severance taxes in the nation — 10 percent.

Even at that rate, his campaign argues, Pennsylvania’s tax wouldn’t be as high as those in some other states including North Dakota, Montana and Alaska.

It would provide enough money to continue sending funds to rural areas of the state that now get impact fees, while leaving hundreds of millions of dollars to spread around the state, said McCord spokesman Mark Nivens.

Pennsylvania is among the top states in natural gas production, yet is unique because it doesn’t charge a severance tax, according to a 2012 report by the National Conference of State Legislatures.

An analysis released last week by the state’s Independent Fiscal Office noted that a well’s value increases as it produces more gas. That means the “effective tax rate” of the state’s current impact fee — not tied to production — shrinks with time.

Just three years ago, the impact fee was the equivalent of a 5.5 percent severance tax. The IFO estimates, in 2014, it will amount to a 1.9 percent in tax on gas production.

The dwindling return makes it easier for lawmakers and gubernatorial candidates to argue that a severance tax could be increased in a way that continues to pour money into communities now receiving a cut of the impact fee while leaving millions for the rest of the state.

The state is projected to receive $224 million in impact fees this year, according to the Public Utility Commission. Most of it goes to counties and communities where drilling occurs.

About 20 percent of those local dollars goes to communities in the district represented by Sen. Gene Yaw, R-Lycoming County. He said the money has paid for all sorts of things including extending water and sewer service, a YMCA, housing programs, municipal equipment and bridge repairs.

Bills currently circulating through the Capitol could raise up to $937 million through a combination of impact fees and severance taxes, according to estimates by the Senate Democratic Caucus.

Despite what proponents promise, Yaw said he’s skeptical that money for rural communities now tied to the impact fees would survive the legislative process.

“I guarantee we’re not going to get that money,” he said. “It’s a matter of where the votes are.”


Text Only | Photo Reprints
  • Yauger.jpg Yauger’s Mercer County trial on hold

    A pending criminal trial for the former Midwestern Intermediate Unit IV executive director has been continued again in Mercer County.

    July 9, 2014 1 Photo

  • Yauger.jpg Yauger now facing federal charge

    With Mercer County court proceedings pending this week, Cecelia Yauger faces federal prosecution for alleged business credit card misuse.

    July 8, 2014 1 Photo

  • school.jpg New Castle board adopts budget despite uncertainty

    The New Castle school board adopted its 2014-15 budget Monday but may have to re-open it next week. The $5.4 million budget, introduced in May, has no tax increase and will not tap into the fund balance. Taxes remain at 17.72 mills.

    July 2, 2014 1 Photo

  • Todora.jpg Board, staff bids farewell to superintendent

    Dr. Mary Todora will retire Monday from the Neshannock school district. “I remember eight and a half years ago when Dr. John Dietz (then-board president) called to tell me I got the job. I was thrilled,” Todora said at her final board meeting.

    June 26, 2014 1 Photo

  • Rich.jpg Vo-tech administrators get bonuses, no raises

    Lawrence County Career and Technical Center administrators will get one-time bonuses instead of raises next year. The joint operating committee approved one-year agreements that would freeze the salaries of director Leonard A. Rich and the principal, head custodian, cafeteria supervisor and computer technician.

    June 24, 2014 1 Photo

  • FrankAloi.jpg Frank Aloi: 50 years of school spirit in Ellwood City

    Frank Aloi is a true Wolverine. Aloi, who turned 73 Friday, spent the past half-century affiliated with the Ellwood City school district and its sports teams.

    June 22, 2014 2 Photos

  • FrankAloi.JPG Frank Aloi Retiring: Ellwood superintendent leaving amid budget woes

    Frank Aloi is retiring next month as Ellwood City’s superintendent of schools. Aloi, a 50-year district employee and its superintendent for nearly 12, submitted his retirement notice to the board during an executive session prior to Thursday’s meeting. His last day is July 16.

    June 17, 2014 1 Photo

  • school.jpg District mulls building sale options

    The New Castle school district is considering selling its three recently closed buildings through a sealed bid process.

    June 11, 2014 1 Photo

  • Perfect.jpg Your Education: Shenango grad never missed a day

    They say nobody’s perfect. But for 13 years, Jenna DiGiammarino certainly was. When Jenna left last night’s commencement ceremonies at Shenango High School, she did so not only with a diploma in hand, but also with a flawless record of attendance dating back to Day One of kindergarten.

    June 7, 2014 1 Photo

  • 03.jpg Photo Gallery, Story: Three New Castle schools close today for good

    Today is bittersweet for New Castle Area School District elementary students and teachers. Three buildings packed with history as longtime learning institutions are closing their doors for good.

    June 5, 2014 1 Photo

House Ads

Have you held or will you hold a garage/yard sale this year?

I have and it was a success! It's a great way to get rid of some junk and make a little extra pocket money.
I have, but it didn't go over so well. Better luck next time?
I haven't yet, but I plan to.
I haven't and I don't plan to. It's not for me.
     View Results