New Castle News

Closer Look

February 8, 2014

Court denies city’s petition in McGaffic case

NEW CASTLE — The city of New Castle has lost another round in a case regarding the disposition of a downtown property.

The Pennsylvania Supreme Court this week denied the city’s petition for appeal of a 4-3 Commonwealth Court decision.

Commonwealth Court ruled last July that Robert W. McGaffic and George Love have standing to recover payment for breach of contract concerning the former Centennial Building.

The property at the corner of East Washington and Mill streets is now part of Cascade Center at the Riverplex. McGaffic and Love are the previous owners of the property.

Commonwealth Court’s decision was a reversal of Senior Judge Michael J. Wherry’s ruling in Lawrence County court.

Attorney Jonathan Solomon, who represents McGaffic, believes this week’s decision ends the case.

“I think it’s the end of the road,” he said Friday.

The Supreme Court’s denial, he said, means the Commonwealth Court decision stands.

“And we have a judgment against the city of New Castle.”

That judgment — as of September — is $2,373,342.88, he said. In addition to the building cost, the figure includes attorney fees and interest that has accrued over the years. The case originated in 1978 when the plaintiffs filed suit.

In 1994, a board of viewers valued the building at $184,000 retroactive to April 12, 1973.

Attorney Samuel Kamin, counsel for the city, reacted, “At this point, we’re analyzing the decision.”

He said Wherry’s decision only addressed the issue of standing.

“It did not address the other issues.”

Kamin said there are other issues still pending. One is whether the city breached a 1977 “closeout agreement” with the New Castle Redevelopment Authority.

In his ruling in December 2011, Wherry dismissed McGaffic and Love’s claim that the city had breached a contract relating to the closeout agreement.

The agreement stated the city would assume debts and liabilities of the redevelopment authority. The case before Wherry was whether the plaintiffs were intended beneficiaries of the closeout agreement.

Kamin argued in the city’s petition to the Supreme Court that the majority opinion of Commonwealth Court departs from established previously by the state Supreme and Superior courts and Commonwealth Court.


Text Only | Photo Reprints
Closer Look
  • Shreck.tiff Schreck reappointed Shenango superintendent

    Dr. Michael Schreck has been reappointed as Shenango’s superintendent for a five-year term. The school board approved his reappointment by an 8-0 vote Monday. Nicholas Manolis was absent.

    April 16, 2014 1 Photo

  • vote.jpg Congressional candidate disqualified

    Commonwealth Court has removed a Democratic candidate for the 3rd Congressional District seat from the May 20 primary ballot. Judge Bernard L. McGinley has invalidated the nomination petitions of Mel A. Marin of Sharon.

    April 16, 2014 1 Photo

  • money.jpg Up through the ground comes education cash

    Democrats running for governor seem to be competing to convince voters they will dip deepest into the pockets of gas drillers to replace $1 billion that Gov. Tom Corbett has cut from education spending.

    April 15, 2014 1 Photo

  • money.jpg Shenango passes tax abatement

    Shenango Township supervisors unanimously approved a tax abatement for Blackwatch Properties LLC when they met Thursday.

    April 14, 2014 1 Photo

  • manna.jpg John K. Manna: Proposals in Harrisburg fail to reflect reality

    My, how time flies. The city of New Castle is in already in its eighth year as a distressed municipality under state Act 47.

    April 12, 2014 1 Photo

  • amish.tiff Officers wear Amish women’s garb to lure suspect

    Two police officers posing as Amish women tried to catch a man who reportedly was exposing himself to Amish children.

    April 11, 2014 1 Photo

  • United Way reports funds raised for pool renovation

    United Way of Lawrence County has raised $51,363 toward the renovation of the Cascade Park swimming pool. Gayle Young, United Way executive director, reported the amount this week.

    April 11, 2014

  • gavel.jpg Shenango to consider tax abatement

    The Shenango Township supervisors will consider offering a five-year sliding tax abatement for businesses at a special meeting Thursday.

    April 10, 2014 1 Photo

  • Paterno memorial gaining support in PSU trustees election

    Former lieutenant governor Bob Jubelirer has joined Penn State supporters calling for the return of the Joe Paterno statue that once stood outside Beaver Stadium.

    April 10, 2014

  • Road.jpg PennDOT to resurface Route 18

    Plans are under way to resurface a nine-mile stretch of Route 18 in southern Lawrence County. Dan Cessna, Pennsylvania Department of Transportation district manager, told the Lawrence County commissioners Tuesday that is one project that has been added since the Lawrence County road work for this year was announced last week.

    April 9, 2014 1 Photo

House Ads
Seasonal Content
Section Teases
Must Read
Continuous Super Bowl Coverage