New Castle News

Closer Look

January 25, 2014

John K. Manna: Rationale for rejected Voter ID law remains suspicous

NEW CASTLE — Back in 2011, state Rep. Daryl Metcalfe said House Bill 934 was needed “to ensure our system has integrity.”

Metcalfe, a Butler County Republican, was the prime sponsor of the bill requiring voters to provide a state-approved photo identification when voting.

The measure was eventually passed by the Legislature in 2012, mostly along party lines, and was signed into law by Gov. Tom Corbett.

Last week, a Commonwealth Court judge struck down the law. Judge Bernard McGinley said the law essentially would make it difficult for hundreds of thousands of registered voters to cast ballots.

“Voting laws are designed to assure a free and fair election,” he wrote. “The voter ID law does not further that goal.”

As of this writing, Corbett has not said whether he would appeal the decision to state Supreme Court. He and staunch supporters of the law have said they believe it is necessary to prevent voter fraud.

A ruling by the Supreme Court — if it decides to hear the case — will be based on legal grounds and whether the law  disenfranchises voters.

Practically speaking, however, laws are usually created to fill a void or meet some need. Unlike most legislation, the voter ID law was not created in response to any known need.

Metcalfe said in 2011 that there had been “many instances of voter fraud and election fraud that have been perpetrated in the state.”

Yet, those supporting the law could provide no evidence of voter fraud occurring in the state.

In fact, the Butler County elections director, told me in 2011that she had worked in the elections office since 2007 and had not seen any evidence of fraud.

Apparently, Metcalfe had not discussed his proposal with the person in his county or asked for any evidence of fraud.

I would think that those who are on the front lines of voting — the election directors who actually experience any problems at the polls — would be the people whom legislators would consult to get the facts.

That is troubling. Is it any wonder then why there is speculation about the real motivation for creating this law?

Text Only | Photo Reprints
Closer Look
  • phone.jpg Attorney general warns of phone scams

    Assorted scams in the commonwealth have prompted a warning from the Pennsylvania Attorney General’s Office. Attorney General Kathleen G. Kane said several scams have been reported to the Bureau of Consumer Protection in recent weeks.

    July 30, 2014 1 Photo

  • disability.jpg Disabilities group unveils new icon

    Disability Options Network is joining forces with the Accessible Icon Project. Officials of the community organization, located at 1929 E. Washington St., said its new icon will replace the current international symbol for accessibility.

    July 29, 2014 1 Photo

  • well.jpg Auditor: State doesn’t have enough inspectors to monitor wells

    The state’s 83 well inspectors face a daunting enough challenge keeping tabs on 120,000 active oil and gas wells that have been drilled over the last century.


    July 29, 2014 1 Photo

  • vote.jpg Independent hopefuls may widen gubernatorial field

    Just when Pennsylvania voters were getting used to the idea of a gubernatorial election showdown between Republican incumbent Tom Corbett and Democratic challenger Tom Wolf, other hopefuls may soon be joining the fray.

    July 28, 2014 1 Photo

  • manna.jpg John K. Manna: Measuring the money

    Should we even bother to have an election in November? By some accounts, maybe the results of some contests are already in.

    July 26, 2014 1 Photo

  • shooting.jpg Man injured in city shooting

    A man was flown to a Pittsburgh hospital Thursday morning following a shooting on West Lincoln Avenue.


    July 25, 2014 1 Photo

  • police.jpg Police: Man pulls gun on construction workers

    Construction workers in Neshannock Township flagged down police Thursday claiming a business owner had pulled a gun on them.


    July 25, 2014 1 Photo

  • Shooting.jpg Shooting witness arrested for giving false name

    State police have arrested a second Detroit area man after questioning him about Sunday’s fatal shooting in Ellwood City. DeMarco Dorian Hoskins, 22, of Highland Park, Mich., was the third man in a private car that transported the deceased to look for a hospital. Hoskins allegedly gave police a false identity when they questioned him as witness.

    July 24, 2014 1 Photo

  • bridgerepair.jpg PennDOT seeks outside help to make bridge repairs

    State officials are poised to sign a massive deal that will enlist outside help to rebuild and maintain up to 600 bridges, marking the Corbett administration’s latest foray into privatizing key government functions.


    July 24, 2014 1 Photo

  • GALLO_Natalie.jpg County native plays Clinton intern

    Natalie Gallo isn’t an intern, but she’s playing one on the New York stage.


    July 24, 2014 1 Photo

House Ads
Seasonal Content
Section Teases
Must Read
Continuous Super Bowl Coverage