NEW CASTLE —
There are seemingly countless ways to tax people.
And these days, there are seemingly countless proposals for dramatically altering — or even eliminating — various taxes.
But whenever there is talk about eliminating or curtailing a tax, a fundamental question needs to be asked: Then what?
It’s easy to draw support for proposals to do away with a tax. No one really wants to pay them. Yet if a government stops collecting a tax, it no longer receives the money. What will it cut from its budget or where it will make up the loss?
In Harrisburg, there are efforts afoot to eliminate property taxes in Pennsylvania. This is a levy imposed by school districts, counties and municipalities. In many instances, it’s the major source of revenue, and for counties it’s usually the sole source of local funds.
Various proposals are being bandied about in the state capital regarding a replacement for the property tax. One, for instance, would increase the state sales tax to 7 percent, while another would boost the state income tax from 3.07 to 4.01 percent.
Any such move would dramatically alter Pennsylvania’s tax and political landscape. Local officials no longer would have to worry about facing the wrath of voters contending with property tax increases. On the other hand, municipalities and school districts would be at the utter mercy of Harrisburg if the power to levy taxes is taken away.
The concept is a slap in the face to those who argue that local control in government works best.
Obviously, doing away with the property tax has its appeal. Older homeowners, for instance, complain about paying property taxes to local schools when they don’t have children attending classes.
On the other hand, paying property taxes to municipalities makes considerable sense. Police, fire and road maintenance services all tend to be property based. Why shouldn’t property taxes pay for them?
And let’s not forget that the major benefit of property taxes is their reliability. For the most part, people make it a point to pay property taxes. In an economic downturn, income and sales taxes drop significantly.
One ongoing problem with the property tax is its somewhat subjective nature. Currently, Allegheny County is going through all sorts of gyrations over a court-ordered property reassessment process that county politicians have been fighting tooth and nail.
In response, the Pennsylvania House of Representatives recently passed a bill — by a unanimous vote — that would permit counties to ignore court-ordered reassessments.
The move may be popular in some circles, but it completely ignores the reality that court-ordered reassessments in Pennsylvania are very rare. And when they occur, it’s because local officials have shirked their responsibility to ensure fair and accurate property valuations.
In Allegheny County, officials have allowed property assessments to become a nightmare. As a result, taxes are unfairly imposed — and the heaviest burden usually falls upon low-income, older neighborhoods.
So the Pennsylvania House is saying it doesn’t care about unfair taxation. It just wants to help fellow politicians duck their duties.
There are legitimate reasons to review tax policies and question how things are being done. But taxpayers need to be aware of when they are being helped and when they are being manipulated.
NEW CASTLE —
There are seemingly countless ways to tax people.
- Mitchel Olszak
Mitchel Olszak: Excuses for data sweep sound hollow
Perhaps 2013 will go down as the year privacy and civil liberties became too inconvenient for government. Listening to assorted officials defend massive programs that scoop up vast amounts of data certainly gives that impression.
Mitchel Olszak: Casino satire comes to fruition
Several years ago, I wrote a satirical column about government subsidizing casinos. In it, I envisioned a time in the future when casinos became so prevalent that the gambling market was glutted with them.
Mitchel Olszak: The challenge in life is to make certain that we live it
Many years ago, I worked as a reporter covering the police beat. The job involved a paper in a small town. And while much of this news consisted of burglaries, fights, drunk driving arrests, etc., I would get the occasional call for a fatality.
Mitchel Olszak: State records reveal water problems with gas well drilling
The drilling of shale gas in Lawrence County and the rest of Pennsylvania holds great promise. It also holds the potential for harm. Depending on who you ask, health and environmental concerns about shale gas drilling are either very real or very overblown.
Mitchel Olszak: Snooping threat to the free press
In “All the President’s Men,” reporter Bob Woodward conducts late-night meetings with a source in a parking garage. That source, Deep Throat (later revealed to be high-ranking FBI official Mark Felt), was worried that he would be exposed as a tipster in the Watergate scandal.
Mitchel Olszak: Toomey takes a chance on guns
How does a conservative Republican senator representing a state with a Democratic majority protect himself politically? One way is to take positions that tend to straddle the nation’s ideological fence.
Mitchel Olszak: Terrorists strive to create fear
The finish line of a road race serves as the division between one world and another. Ahead of the finish line, there is structure and discipline, with attention paid to the runners as they cross over. Spectators are kept back, mainly to avoid interfering with the participants — and perhaps to keep them from being trampled.
Mitchel Olszak: Kelly, allies battle arms treaty
Supporters of the right to bear arms have a champion in Congressman Mike Kelly. The federal lawmaker, whose district includes most of Lawrence County, has been making waves with his criticism of the Obama administration and its support for the United Nations Arms Trade Treaty.
Mitchel Olszak: I like beer, so I’m watching our state closely
I like beer. More to the point, I like good beer. In my younger days, just about any swill would do. But with the passage of time, sophistication and exposure to the possibilities, my interests in beer have sharpened and matured.
Mitchel Olszak: Political lessons from distant past hold value today
If you want to gain an appreciation for great thinkers, read some of history’s major political philosophies. Here you will find the works of Plato, Machiavelli, Locke, Hobbes, Rousseau, St. Augustine and many others. They explored difficult social issues and offered serious insight.
- More Mitchel Olszak Headlines
- Mitchel Olszak: Excuses for data sweep sound hollow