CNHI —
The New Castle Area School Board has cited apparent deficiencies in denying a charter school application.
The board conducted two public hearings prior to its 8-0 vote Thursday.
Debra Rice, charter school leader, said the school’s organizers plan to meet today with an attorney to decide their next step.
New Castle’s school solicitor, acting superintendent, business manager and other administrators had perused the plan and cited several pages of what they believe are deficiencies in the application of the New Castle Arts Academy Charter School.
These recommendations were adopted by the board as a resolution which concludes that each identified deficiency “is sufficiently serious to warrant denial of the charter application.”
Shortcomings cited in the resolution include:
•There is no indication that any of three possible downtown sites for the school is adequate for the grades to be served. The applicant failed to provide drawings, renditions, outlines or simple sketch of any of the proposed sites. Nor is there documentation that steps were taken to ensure the health and safety of the students as mandated.
•The applicant’s rent budget is unrealistic.
•The application fails to show sustainable support for the school by teachers, parents, other community members and students. Two people spoke in support of the school at a public hearing — one of whom lives outside the school district, the other is a member of the applicant’s board of trustees. Of three others commenting, two opposed the application and one asked a question.
Of the 33 signatures on a petition in support of the charter school, 27 percent of those signing live outside the district. Of a total of 52 pre-enrollment forms submitted to the district, 32 percent were from individuals who live outside of the district. According to state statutes, charter school support must be from within and not outside of the community.
•There are discrepancies in listing advisory board and founding members. At least one person on the list denies being part of the process.
•There is an apparent lack of mission and educational goals regarding state academic standards for math, reading, writing, speaking and listening.
•The curriculum is general and does not show any art infused into any course. The instruction method for reading, an important aspect of elementary curriculum, is lacking.
•Textbooks and instructional materials are not clearly identified.
•The application fails to show how the school will verify teacher qualifications or obtain “highly qualified” world language teachers.
•No remediation is offered for students who don’t succeed in world languages.
•Demographic data indicates about 20 percent of the students would need English language learning support, but there is no detail or budget for such programs.
•Support for special needs students is not calculated into the budget, nor are there specific allocations for a school psychologist, speech therapist, occupational therapist or other support services.
•Title I revenues are based on an 85 percent free and reduced lunch population. The district’s free and reduced percentage is closer to 70 percent.
•The applicant provided no information about its ability to borrow money should the school need funds. Additional concerns are its projection of the state employees retirement system, which shows a $31,000 budget shortfall, and inadequate funding for student health care.
“The district cannot make a sound fiscal decision when financial data submitted by the applicant is inaccurate, inconsistent and not reflective of sustainable business practice.”
•There is no plan of action should pending legislation pass make charter school funding more equitable and decrease funding.
•While the applicant has designated grades 4 through 8 will be represented at the school, there is no budget.
(Email: dwachter@ncnewsonline.com)
New Castle
Related Photos
Discussion
Resolution details charter school denial
- New Castle
-
-
New Castle Schools: Finding pinpoints nonpaying out-of-district pupils
New Castle school board members are waiting for the final determinations of a state audit that contained three preliminary findings. Earlier this month the board publicly discussed those findings from the 2009-10 and 2010-11 school years, and the district administration has responded to two of them to the Pennsylvania Department of the Auditor General.
-
Primary 2013: School board candidate tops campaign spending
Historically, spending by school board candidates has paled in comparison to those running for other local offices. But not this year, at least with one candidate — George J. Gabriel.
-
Our Opinion: We endorse candidates for New Castle board
The New Castle school district is often a study in contrasts. There are complaints about the district on everything from taxes to nepotism, from test scores to ethical slights. Yet at the same time, plenty of students within the district excel. It’s a tribute to the hard work of those students, their families and the educators who support them.
-
New Castle Basketball: Former 'Canes' standout to play professionally
New Castle High graduate and Slippery Rock University basketball standout Devin Taylor is going pro. Taylor signed a professional contract yesterday to play for the Etzella Ettelbruck Basketball Club in Luxembourg for the 2013-2014 season.
-
Making a Difference: Custodian makes clean sweep of kids’ hearts
When Croton Pre-Kindergarten Center students recess for summer vacation next month, “Mr. Pete” will walk out the door with them. And it will be for the last time.
-
Emergency school calls show lack of foresight
Editor, The News: On April 30, we had the horrible experience of being alerted by phone that our daughter, a student at George Washington, was one of 700 students relocated to tennis courts because of a gas line break and could be picked up there.
-
Special Section: You can say ‘thank you’ to the ’Canes!
It was a season like no other in New Castle basketball history. Now, it’s time to say thanks for the special memories. You can share your gratitude with members of the team and coaching staff in a special section we’re producing at The News.
-
Gas line rupture: Police say ‘massive’ school evacuation went smoothly
It was a scene reminiscent of the Pied Piper of Hamelin. About 700 children left the George Washington Intermediate Elementary School and marched eight blocks to the Park Avenue tennis courts Tuesday morning after workers hit a gas line.
-
Gas line rupture forces school evacuation
George Washington Intermediate Elementary School was evacuated this morning. A reported gas line rupture forced students from the school. They were transported to the playground at the corner of Park Avenue and North Mercer Street.
-
New Castle students weather storm to clean up community
On a gray, rainy day, more than 270 New Castle High School students took to the streets. They took to the parks and the playgrounds, too, getting their hands wet and dirty yesterday during the annual city cleanup.
- More New Castle Headlines
-
