NEW CASTLE —
If it isn’t broken, don’t break it.
That’s essentially what a committee made up of New Castle city officials decided in exploring whether the city should pursue a home rule charter.
After studying the pros and cons of placing a question on the ballot for the last few months, the committee recommended against pursuing the idea.
Formation of the committee was a directive in the city’s Act 47 financial recovery plan. A major reason for doing so was that it would provide the city more flexibility with its taxes, and overcome one hurdle to exit Act 47 status.
Act 47 gives the city the ability to have a wage tax above the state limit of 1 percent on city residents. The tax now is at 2.15 percent and generates about $2.5 million in revenue.
If the city were no longer under Act 47, it would have to lower the tax to 1 percent and, therefore, lose the $2.5 million in revenue it desperately needs. However, the city could impose a tax above the state limit through a home rule charter that would have to be approved by the voters.
While city officials like that aspect of home rule, they believe the process has some drawbacks.
Once a government study commission would be approved by the voters, city officials would have no control over the process. Although the city’s intent may be to only consider taxes, the commission would have wide latitude to look at other aspects of the government.
In fact, a study commission would not be obligated to even consider lifting the ceiling on the wage tax.
But the commission would have the authority to recommend changing from the current mayor-council form of government to something else. And that’s a key concern for city officials.
One point worthy of note in the committee’s report of its study is that there is no sentiment in the community to pursue certain changes over others. Actually, there is no community sentiment to make any changes, including changing the form of government that has been in existence since 1968.
So, it appears New Castle will be under Act 47 status for some time to come. And what is wrong with that? Act 47 has provided the city with financial stability over the last five years, something that would not have occurred otherwise.
NEW CASTLE —
If it isn’t broken, don’t break it.
- John K. Manna
John K. Manna: State says some local people have high incomes
A lot of people fantasize about becoming instant millionaires. That’s why millions of Americans play the lottery, particularly when the jackpots for Powerball and Mega Millions exceed $100 million.
John K. Manna: Son of football legend leads political field in poll
Jay Paterno announced last week that he will be a Democratic candidate for lieutenant governor in the May primary. Earlier this week, a poll showed Paterno leading the field of Democratic candidates for lieutenant governor by a slim margin.
John K. Manna: Distressed status gives city more revenue sources
New Castle’s population decline over the years has been well documented. It may be small consolation, but most cities in the Northeast have experienced a migration of residents to the suburbs or the Sun Belt over the last 50 years or so.
John K. Manna: Governor’s stances appear to shift over time
Where did Gov. Tom Corbett get his ideas? I don’t know if anyone has ever asked that question, but it came to me this week after reading a column written by G. Terry Madonna and Michael L. Young.
John K. Manna: Survey data suggest governor faces re-election struggle
While public opinion polls are conducted throughout the year, this is the time of year they may carry more significance. Primarily because we are entering a new political campaign season, one in which Pennsylvania voters will be electing a governor.
John K. Manna: Rationale for rejected Voter ID law remains suspicous
Back in 2011, state Rep. Daryl Metcalfe said House Bill 934 was needed “to ensure our system has integrity.” Metcalfe, a Butler County Republican, was the prime sponsor of the bill requiring voters to provide a state-approved photo identification when voting.
John K. Manna: State acts to give public more information
When someone suggests, for example, that school property taxes be replaced with state funding, school officials object. And why? They contend that local control would be diminished as a result. I find it laughable since school districts really have little local control now.
John K. Manna: Council members clash on filling empty slot
What a way to begin a new session of New Castle City Council. If this is a honeymoon, I can’t imagine what the divorce may look like. Not that I’m predicting any kind of irreconcilable differences among members of council, but they got off to a rocky start Thursday night in attempting to fill a vacancy on council.
John K. Manna: City school board contest saw plenty of campaign spending
This has been an unusual year for politics in Lawrence County. It’s been a highly uneventful year, except perhaps for those who won election to public office.
John K. Manna: Party labels shouldn’t matter in local contests
Anything is possible in elections, but often improbable when it comes to school board races in Pennsylvania. In the Nov. 5 election, voters went to the polls in six of the eight school districts in Lawrence County and were faced with little choice.
- More John K. Manna Headlines
- John K. Manna: State says some local people have high incomes