New Castle News

Local News

Discussion

July 6, 2007

Pain expert testifies in oxycodone doctor’s trial

By Debbie Wachter Morris

An expert pain management doctor testified yesterday that untreated chronic pain will break down the human body.

Dr. Forest Tennant was summoned from West Covina, Calif., to testify in defense of Dr. William Mangino, a pain medicine doctor being prosecuted for alleged Medicaid fraud and violations of the state’s drug act.

Tennant, who runs a pain research clinic, was the only defense witness in the case, which is expected to go to the jury today after closing arguments.

Attorney Thomas W. Leslie questioned Tennant, who said Mangino’s practice followed pain medicine standards when he worked as a consultant in a Union Township clinic with two other doctors.

His testimony contradicted that of prosecution witness Dr. David Evanko, who spent most of last week on the witness stand. Evanko, a Butler physician, testified about addictive pain medicine, saying Mangino’s work was not in accordance with the acceptable standards of the pain medicine profession, according to deputy state attorney general Jeff Baxter.

Tennant testified that pain management medicine has evolved within the past 10 years and standards have been developed to evaluate it.

“Some doctors have raised their hands and said they want to get into this,” he said.

According to Tennant, opioids — narcotics including oxycodone — are the backbone of chronic pain management for people “on the athletic field, on the battlefield and in the clinic.”

Tennant, a founder of the American Society of Addiction Medicine, said the standards are that a doctor has to believe the patient and provide enough relief for the pain without sedating or impairing the patient.

He defined chronic pain as acute pain lasting more than three months, and that “opioids are the way to go when the other things are not working.

“Pain itself is a deadly disease,” Tennant said, noting it can cause detrimental hormone changes in the brain, spinal cord and adrenal glands.

“People with acute pain start rusting out from the inside if they don’t get pain relief, and it’s important to treat pain,” he said.

Tennant said the state board of medicine pain management standards were developed in 1985 in California by the California Board of Addictive Medicine while he was a member of the board.

“We wanted doctors to keep good records if they were going to prescribe medicine,” he said.

Tennant viewed files of 11 of Mangino’s patients and commented that the guidelines for pain management “were quite well followed. I felt the records were well up to the standards and met the regulations.

“Dr. Mangino did not start any of these people on opioids,” he continued. “I think he was following what he was taught in all of the (pain management) courses.”

Mangino, whom he had not met until yesterday, faces 11 charges of violating the state drug act, one count of conspiracy to violate the act, six counts of Medicaid fraud and one charge of conspiracy to commit Medicaid fraud.

He was accused — along with chiropractor Thomas Wilkins and pain management doctor Phillip Wagman — of running a “prescription mill” in their pain management clinic by prescribing large quantities of addictive narcotics including oxycodone.

Wagman and Wilkins were tried together last year and convicted. They are serving their sentences in state prisons.

Text Only | Photo Reprints
Local News
  • 11.jpg Photo Gallery: Freedom Fair celebrates ‘Access for All’

    Riverwalk Park hosted the third annual Freedom Fair on Saturday. The event, sponsored by the Disability Options Network, was billed as a celebration of “Liberty, Justice and Access for All.”

    May 21, 2012 1 Photo 1 Story

  • read.tiff Middle schoolers swarm to reading festival

    The rewards of reading are fruitful, and, as the participants in this year’s Lawrence County Reading Festival would say, sweet. Yesterday, fourth-, fifth-, and sixth-graders from nearly every school in the county participated in the  festival at George Washington Intermediate School.

    May 19, 2012 1 Photo

  • Bridge restrictions set for Maitland Lane

    Work on a project to rehabilitate the bridge that carries East Maitland Lane over Neshannock Creek will begin next week. The work, in Neshannock and Hickory townships, will be weather permitting.

    May 19, 2012

  • money.jpg Union proposes budget without tax hike

    Union’s school board introduced a $10 million budget with no tax increase for 2012-13. However, cuts in personnel and programs are being proposed in order to balance the budget.

    May 18, 2012 1 Photo

  • Judge to speak at Croton service

    Lawrence County’s president judge, Dominick Motto, will be the featured speaker at Sunday’s Croton Memorial service. The 2 p.m. program at the Croton Honor Roll is designed to remember America’s veterans.

    May 18, 2012

  • Union’s housing rehab money declining

    The amount of money for housing rehabilitation in Union Township is declining. The supervisors accepted $88,352 in 2012-2013 Community Development Block Grant Funds at a special meeting Wednesday.

    May 18, 2012

  • Postal.jpg Eight county post offices face cut in hours

    Eight rural post offices in Lawrence County could see reduced hours under a proposal by the U.S. Postal Service. The offices being considered are in Edinburg, Enon Valley, Hillsville, New Bedford, Pulaski, Villa Maria, Wampum and West Pittsburg.

    May 17, 2012 1 Photo

  • Police conduct DUI checkpoint

    Local and state police joined forces to look for drunk drivers last weekend. Between 11 p.m. Saturday and 3 a.m. Sunday, state and Shenango Township police cooperating in a DUI checkpoint stopped 234 motorists.

    May 17, 2012

  • school.jpg Neshannock to establish cyber academy

    Neshannock will begin a cyber/charter school next year. The board last week agreed to contract with VLN Partners of Pittsburgh. The district will pay a $16,750 annual fee for the customized online plan plus an additional $150 for each student who participates in the program and each teacher who taps into its resources.

    May 16, 2012 1 Photo

  • Farm market vouchers are available to seniors

    Lawrence County’s Senior Farmers Market Program will start June 11 and continue until supplies run out. Eligible seniors can receive four $5 vouchers one time only in 2012 to be used at approved farmers markets.

    May 16, 2012