NEW CASTLE —
Editor, The News:
I am replying to Matthew Finamore’s May 3 letter criticizing the newspaper for publishing Joseph Waltenbaugh’s letter criticizing gay marriage.
While I don’t condone anything Waltenbaugh said, I respectfully disagree with Finamore’s position that The News shouldn’t have published that letter.
I agree with Finamore’s position on equal rights for same sex couples, but at the same time, we do have the First Amendment. The First Amendment protects Waltenbaugh’s right to express his opinion, while also protecting Finamore’s right to scrutinize his opinion.
In the letter, Finamore said he wanted to have “an intelligent discourse” on the impacts of same sex marriage. My question for him would be what he views that to be, if he thinks that Waltenbaugh’s letter doesn’t intellectually contribute to that discourse he speaks of.
The problem with his argument is that the letter he finds to be unintelligent might be viewed as an intelligent viewpoint to someone else. Therefore, one can argue that intelligent discourse is in the eye of the beholder.
He added that it is the news publication’s job to serve as “facilitators” of public discourse. I agree with him there, as someone who worked in the college newspaper editorial staff for three years.
I just fail to see what The News did wrong, considering I learned in journalism that it would be our job to present both sides of the issue. As long as the letters didn’t go over the word count and could be backed up, just about anything was published.
To conclude, I applaud The News for publishing both their letters, and letting the readers make up their own minds. If you believe the public opinion polls, Finamore is winning the argument.
East Winter Avenue
NEW CASTLE —
Editor, The News:
- Letters to the Editor
Letter to the Editor E-form
Send Letter to the Editor E-form
School musicals earn praise from attendee
Editor, The News: One thing I love about spring are the musicals the local high schools perform.
GOP shows no concern for those sent to war
Editor, The News: Here I go again.
Exploiting state champs in order to make money
Editor, The News: It’s been a few weeks since the New Castle boys basketball team capped off a tremendous season by winning the state championship.
Sebelius resignation follows vow to fight
Editor, The News: Kathleen Sebelius was honored at a garden party to celebrate her resignation and the pseudo fact that she orchestrated the signup of 7.5 million people into Obamacare.
Public offered praise for school art show
Editor, The News: We usually procrastinate on writing letters to anyone, but this one was on the top of our list of things to do.
Government must serve all people in the nation
Editor, The News: Bernie Sanders is thinking about running for president.
Failing to watch Fox means missing news
Editor, The News: Leftist Michigan Democratic Congressman John Dingell, talking about Obamacare said, “It takes a long time to do the necessary administrative steps that have to be taken to put legislation together to control the people.”
America’s politicians must serve as leaders
Editor, The News: We love our families and this great country, but looking ahead doesn’t it gives us pause to be concerned about our grandkids and great-grandkids?
Clarence Thomas, wife raise conflict concerns
Editor, The News: As expected and lacking citation, Tea Partier Patty Jenkins maliciously diverts unfounded attention to President Obama instead of Clarence Thomas as the true culprit of shredding the Constitution (March 20).
- More Letters to the Editor Headlines
- Letter to the Editor E-form