New Castle News

Letters to the Editor

May 22, 2013

First Amendment provides for differing viewpoints

NEW CASTLE — Editor, The News:

I am replying to Matthew Finamore’s May 3 letter criticizing the newspaper for publishing Joseph Waltenbaugh’s letter criticizing gay marriage.

While I don’t condone anything Waltenbaugh said, I respectfully disagree with Finamore’s position that The News shouldn’t have published that letter.

I agree with Finamore’s position on equal rights for same sex couples, but at the same time, we do have the First Amendment. The First Amendment protects Waltenbaugh’s right to express his opinion, while also protecting Finamore’s right to scrutinize his opinion.

In the letter, Finamore said he wanted to have “an intelligent discourse” on the impacts of same sex marriage. My question for him would be what he views that to be, if he thinks that Waltenbaugh’s letter doesn’t intellectually contribute to that discourse he speaks of.

The problem with his argument is that the letter he finds to be unintelligent might be viewed as an intelligent viewpoint to someone else. Therefore, one can argue that intelligent discourse is in the eye of the beholder.

He added that it is the news publication’s job to serve as “facilitators” of public discourse. I agree with him there, as someone who worked in the college newspaper editorial staff for three years.

I just fail to see what The News did wrong, considering I learned in journalism that it would be our job to present both sides of the issue. As long as the letters didn’t go over the word count and could be backed up, just about anything was published.

To conclude, I applaud The News for publishing both their letters, and letting the readers make up their own minds. If you believe the public opinion polls, Finamore is winning the argument.

Sean Bracken

East Winter Avenue

New Castle

1
Text Only | Photo Reprints
Letters to the Editor
  • Letter to the Editor E-form

    Send Letter to the Editor      E-form

    April 23, 2010

  • A thoughtful gesture marks an anniversary

    August 2, 2014

  • Patriotic attire rule offends veteran

    Editor, The News: On July 2, as I was checking out of our local Wal-Mart, something happened that disturbed me. A cashier went to the cashier in my lane and said orders had come down from the store manager that no one was allowed to wear any patriotic shirts, pins, symbols or anything showing patriotic colors from July 4 to July 11.

    August 1, 2014

  • Do views on baptism match Bible’s words?

    Editor, The News: In regard to the Rev. Randy Crum. He must be reading a different Bible than the Christian religion. What theologian taught him his version?

    July 31, 2014

  • Aging agency offers help with Medicare

    Editor, The News: I am writing in response to the woman who reported problems she was encountering with the high out-of-pocket costs of her Medicare supplemental insurance plan in last Saturday’s “The People Speak.”

    July 30, 2014

  • ‘State Fair’ displays Playhouse possibilities

    Editor, The News: I had a delightful experience attending the New Castle Playhouse opening night performance of “State Fair.”

    July 29, 2014

  • Dreaming of being local meteorologist

    Editor, The News: I always wanted to be a meteorologist. I am never wrong or right and I still have a job. I provide data that no one understands while I am warm and dry waving my arms with that important suit and smug smile.

    July 28, 2014

  • People should check health insurance

    Editor, The News: I have paid the local hospital almost $1,500 in co-payments because my supplemental insurance was turned into a health maintenance organization, which was allowed to override my Medicare coverage.

    July 26, 2014

  • In Bible, Jesus calls for people to repent

    Editor, The News: Recently in the paper, Elton John said he believes Jesus would support same-sex marriages.

    July 26, 2014

  • Scientific knowledge may be something else

    Editor, The News: Science is knowledge derived by method; things scientific meet the criteria of science, but neither the criteria, nor the method are scientific.

    July 25, 2014

House Ads
Poll

Before this weekend's release of the new Marvel film, which previous 'guardians of the galaxy' were your favorite?

The Federation/Star Fleet
The Green Lantern Corps
Jedi Knights
Earth Alliance (Babylon 5)
Space Ghost, Jan, Jace and Blip
     View Results