NEW CASTLE —
Editor, The News:
Answering Bonnie Humphrey’s challenge in a recent letter:
1. The undergirding ground of any argument is the efficacy of the human mind.
2. The human mind can no more justify itself than one may pull oneself by bootstraps.
3. The human mind has relations with “things;” either “creations” of the human mind (idealism, therefore irrational) or independent of the human mind (classical realism, thus rational, the Founders’ position).
If you embrace idealism, and understand its implications, the Constitution can be used to justify anything — eventually — because there is no certainty in the mind’s relation to what is not the mind; thus, unalienable rights e.g., become absurdities, all then is based on how people feel.
Unfortunately, feelings change, sometimes dramatically in short amounts of time. Sentiment informing/determining law is the antithesis of a rule of law.
4. U.S. Constitution presupposes a rational moral order — as the necessary ground for establishing rule of law.
5. The preamble of the U.S. Constitution presupposes — as a necessary condition for approximation of its principles to be realized — dispositions of virtue, i.e., moral dispositions, i.e., beings which limit their appetites to their “final-causality” which is natural law.
6. The Founders — much wiser than all of us moderns — knew that human sentiment is in flux, and can be “pied-pipered” into sentimentally surrendering the constitutional checks and balances — as we have — for transient un-reason.
7. We arrogant modern dimwits have created our problems (e.g., financial collapse, political grid-lock, ubiquity of government, etc.) because we think we know better than the founders — issues like homosexual “marriage” would never reach federal courts if states appointed senators — as they did before the 17th Amendment’s ratification.
Thomas J. Donegan
NEW CASTLE —
Editor, The News:
- Letters to the Editor
Letter to the Editor E-form
Send Letter to the Editor E-form
Wage rates depend on quality of work
Editor, The News: I think everyone should start working for $50 per hour.
Season ticket holders lose championship seats
Editor, The News: The New Castle Area School District has done it again.
Letter writers ignore key details on issues
Editor, The News: In his claim that Hollywood is redefining marriage, Tim Erson writes as a follower of some visionary instead of a follower of God and His love for all His children (letter, Feb. 13).
Strangers provide aid in dangerous situation
Editor, The News: Recently, I was traveling on Valley Road in Neshannock Township. As I approached a sharp bend, I noticed an orange cone on the shoulder, which I figured was there because of a pothole.
Marriage is a function of state, not religion
Editor, The News: Marriage is a state institution with a non-integral religious component. The lines between these have become blurred.
Tax reform proposal would benefit budget
Editor, The News: Most valuable budget plan: Bernie Sanders’ progressive budget blueprint.
Trapping, neutering cats is way to cut population
Editor, The News: The feral/homeless cat population is now over 30 million. No, they don’t all live in Lawrence County, they are “just” in the United States and they are not at fault.
Changes in society are hard to fathom
Editor, The News: I’m 89 years of age and I am wondering what has happened to the society that was fairly constant during the early years of my life. You ask what’s bothering me?
Church soup team hopes it can return
Editor, The News: Due to some circumstances going on now at Shenango Presbyterian Church, the soup team has decided to put the soup making and selling on hold for right now.
- More Letters to the Editor Headlines
- Letter to the Editor E-form