NEW CASTLE —
Editor, The News:
Pre-Socratic justice was helping one’s friends and harming one’s enemies.
A “friend” shared a common interest, but since all such interests are temporary, so were friendships. Note that such — is reality — absent an objective moral order; relationships — including relations of “love” are reduced to practicality.
“I need you for ‘X’ and thus, we are ‘friends,’ or thus, I ‘love’ you.” At the end of the day, that is egoism, and nothing more.
Justice for Socrates/Plato was a soul (nexus of impetuses) ordered in reason, i.e., impetuses limited in accordance with an (intuited, informal) natural law.
Aristotle treats “friendship,” distinguishing the practical, convenient relation from the moral relation, which is predicated upon a natural law — which Aristotle formalizes in Nicomachean ethics.
Aristotle — in formalizing the natural law — was attempting to establish a code of conduct that allowed for a moral common ground; he saw that preferable to “might-makes-right.”
Similarly — regarding Kant’s categorical imperative — he was not attempting to pillory sentimentalists (reason subject to passion) of any variety; he was attempting to establish an a priori universal moral code (since if Kant’s epistemology is true, the natural law is absurd) that would promote amelioration of the human condition.
If I am driving to town, a road, a vehicle and town — amongst many other things — are presupposed. Analogously, the U.S. Constitution presupposes many things e.g., a rational (moral) order, moral agents; ultimately Christendom. Christendom, is not Christianity, rather it is an accompanying rational (philosophical) worldview incorporating Aristotle’s thought; that, to which, Martin Luther ultimately objected.
With the Supreme Court majority decision regarding the Defense of Marriage Act, the court inanely invalidated itself as it an advocate pre-Socratic justice.
NEW CASTLE —
Editor, The News:
- Letters to the Editor
Letter to the Editor E-form
Send Letter to the Editor E-form
Cell phone technology leaves a lot to desire
Editor, The News: The first words spoken by Alexander Graham Bell over a phone were “Watson, come here, I want to see you.”
Funeral home staff helps bring family together
Editor, The News: Our brother passed away on Nov. 12 of an unexpected illness. He was laid to rest knowing that his wife and daughter are also resting beside him.
Promotion of Obamacare was product of deception
Editor, The News: Let us not totally focus on the over $634 million Obamacare website, which was created by a Canadian company (CGI).
Postage stamp promotes holiday for Muslims
Editor, The News: You’re kidding. President Obama has given his permission to the United States of America’s postal system to print a new stamp.
Bear memorial stolen from daughter’s grave
Editor, The News: Someone put a beautiful wooden bear on my daughter’s grave at Oak Park Cemetery.
Medical marijuana has long record of safety
Editor, The News: Re: Local family moving for marijuana treatment, Nov. 20.
Media fail to address black community woes
Editor, The News: Where is the racial leadership with the black community?
County jail operations must stay in public hands
Editor, The News: I have resided in Lawrence County all my life. My mother was employed by the county nursing home.
Community provided support for the troops
Editor, The News: On behalf of the volunteers of Operation Lifeline, we would like to acknowledge the local community for its generosity of time and talent.
- More Letters to the Editor Headlines
- Letter to the Editor E-form