NEW CASTLE —
So now what?
Last week’s conviction of Pennsylvania Supreme Court Justice Joan Orie Melvin on most of the corruption counts against her leads to the question above. What does the commonwealth do now that it has a convicted criminal sitting on the bench of its highest court?
Several options exist. Pennsylvania’s court system, for example, has a mechanism that allows for removal of judges found to have engaged in illegal or unethical activity. And the state’s constitution allows the Legislature to pursue impeachment.
That happened once before, with former Supreme Court Justice Rolf Larsen. But that was an agonizing process, and it tied the Legislature in knots, as lawmakers pursued an action with little precedent. Even if impeachment proceedings were to go more smoothly against Melvin, they almost surely would be slow and cumbersome.
And we suppose the same thing could be said about any action taken by Pennsylvania’s Judicial Conduct Board against Melvin. The process could take months.
This makes us wonder if any such effort is worth it. By the time the Legislature or Judicial Conduct Board is able to act, Melvin most likely will be sentenced on the charges she was convicted of last week. At that point, she automatically will be removed from office.
That’s how it works in Pennsylvania, as astute Lawrence County residents will recall from observing the Gary Felasco saga. The former Lawrence County treasurer — despite a litany of criminal counts and resultant conviction — was able to keep his elected post and its salary until he was sentenced.
The best thing to occur here would be for Melvin to do the right thing and resign. Sometimes that happens with elected officials convicted of crimes in the commonwealth. They at least have the decency to spare the taxpayers any further embarrassment and quietly give up their seats.
But it’s not required, as we learned from Felasco. So far, there’s no indication what Melvin will do. If she persists in claims she is innocent of charges related to the use of state employees for campaign work, the judge could hold on to her seat until sentencing.
One good thing is that Melvin has been on leave from the Supreme Court because of the charges against her. But that means there is a spot on the panel that needs to be filled. However, until she gives up her seat, or is forced from it, Melvin cannot be replaced.
Eventually, Melvin no longer will be a presence on the Supreme Court. That’s an unfortunate end to her career, but it’s an end she crafted for herself. Sadly, using tax dollars for political purposes — by paying state employees to work on campaigns — has been a widespread problem in Pennsylvania. It prompted the Bonusgate investigation.
Perhaps Melvin’s fate can serve a purpose if it reminds state politicians that abusing power in this fashion can carry a heavy cost.
NEW CASTLE —
So now what?
Our Opinion: Ohio’s earthquake response demands Pennsylvania action
Confirmation by Ohio officials that fracking caused several low-level earthquakes near the Lawrence County border warrants attention. Yet it’s by no means clear that Pennsylvania is responding appropriately.
Our Opinion: School attack leads to inevitable questions
Another mass attack at a public school has people grasping for answers. They shouldn’t be surprised if no good explanations are forthcoming.
Our Opinion: Western Europe must embrace energy options
Russian President Vladimir Putin continues to demonstrate that he poses a problem for the West. And like many problems, Putin is one that may be best addressed by bypassing it.
Our Opinion: America may abandon Mideast peace efforts
President Obama may join other American chief executives in coming up short on achieving a Middle East peace. The State Department is sending signals that it may abandon current efforts to negotiate a key agreement between Israel and the Palestinians.
Our Opinion: Health program hits signup mark, but questions linger
So what are we to make of the latest news regarding Obamacare? The Obama administration says more than 7 million people signed up for health insurance under the Affordable Care Act, slightly surpassing early expectations.
Our Opinion: Ban of cash gifts to politicians belatedly imposed
Sometimes it takes massive embarrassment to get people to do the right thing. Proving that is the Pennsylvania Legislature, where this week House leaders ordered a ban on most cash gifts for members.
Our Opinion: Major study finds food link to lower death rate
If there ever was a compelling case that people should eat more fruits and vegetables, this is it. A study in Great Britain examined the eating habits of 65,000 people and came away with some startling results.
Our Opinion: Another census report shows local population drop
Well, it happened again. The latest release of data by the U.S. Census Bureau offered estimates that Lawrence County lost population in 2013.
Our Opinion: Financial failings in local education create concerns
We think it’s safe to say that taxpayers have high expectations of public school systems. After all, they receive considerable public funding to perform the primary task assigned to them — the education of young people.
Our Opinion: What happens if shale gas operations cause earthquakes?
The Pennsylvania Department of Environmental Protection has no plans to take any action regarding several recent earthquakes in Ohio.
- More Editorials Headlines
- Our Opinion: Ohio’s earthquake response demands Pennsylvania action