NEW CASTLE —
Privatization of public services can be a good thing.
But not always. These matters always warrant a case-by case assessment.
Ideally, privatization serves the public interest when it promotes innovation, efficiency and perhaps even some measure of competition. Private businesses handling public services may have a financial incentive to perform better that government agencies don’t possess.
But privatization doesn’t always work. If the move simply creates another level of bureaucracy and adds to consumer costs, what’s the benefit? At times, privatization can be little more than a scheme to direct public funds to politically connected cronies.
The current federal charges involving the former director of the cyber school program in Beaver County could turn out to be an example of that.
Last week, the Corbett administration announced an extension of an agreement with a British firm seeking to privately run the Pennsylvania Lottery. The administration reached such a deal months ago, but it was blocked by Attorney General Kathleen Kane.
Among other things, Kane said the privatization move and expanded gambling options included in the deal were unconstitutional, because Gov. Tom Corbett was acting without legislative approval.
I believe Kane is absolutely correct. Regardless of one’s ideological perspectives on privatization, the lottery is a program created by the Legislature. And lawmakers did not authorize anything close to the changes Corbett is seeking.
Unfortunately, when the governor made his privatization push, his fellow Republicans who control the General Assembly were largely silent. Something tells me that wouldn’t happen if a Democratic governor was advocating it.
I can understand Corbett not wanting to seek lawmaker support for this plan. Getting the Pennsylvania Legislature to do anything of consequence is an ambitious undertaking.
And the governor already has plenty of experience on that point. Just ask him about liquor privatization or transportation funding.
But behind the lottery privatization issue is a more philosophical one. It involves the nature of gambling and government’s seemingly endless desire to squeeze more money from the vice.
In advocating for his lottery privatization plan, Corbett argued an outside firm would be able to generate more revenue for the programs the lottery supports. Yet the reality is that this could happen only through expanded gambling options.
In other words, the state would have to encourage people to bet more frequently on the slim chance of a big payoff.
Critics often describe lottery programs as taxes on the poor, or perhaps the gullible. It’s safe to assume that millionaires don’t bother to play the Daily Number, but people struggling for a few extra bucks do. By using the lottery to fund assorted programs for the elderly in Pennsylvania, the pressure to use tax dollars is decreased.
Defenders argue playing the lottery is a choice, not a tax. True, but from government’s perspective, the only difference is that there are no repercussions from imposing more gambling on the public, but taxes will prompt a reaction.
However, there ought to be repercussions. Gambling does not promote growth or produce a better society. It creates the false promise of something for nothing. And citizens should question government’s growing embrace of vice as a way to grab easy cash.
NEW CASTLE —
Privatization of public services can be a good thing.
Mitchel Olszak: Personal skepticism is best defense against scams
The caller said she had been targeted by a telephone scam. She wanted me to put something in the paper to warn others. I asked if she had contacted police about the matter.
John K. Manna: State finally has road, bridge repair plan
Pennsylvania finally has a program in place to fix roads and bridges and provide more money for mass transit. The massive undertaking — pushed by Republican Gov. Tom Corbett — will cost about $2.3 million per year, most of which will be paid by motorists in the form of increases in gas prices at the pump and fees.
Culinary Conversation: Authors share recipes deer to them
If you want the most knowledgeable information about a subject, go to the authority. In this case, the expert on cooking with venison — deer meat — is Ellwood City’s Steve Loder. He and his wife, Gale, are the authors of “Quality Venison Cookbook — Great Recipes from the Kitchen of Steve and Gale Loder.”
John K. Manna: Three former governors give their endorsements
Another election is history, which means another election campaign season is under way. Actually, some Democratic candidates running in next year’s gubernatorial contest couldn’t wait and began campaigning months before this year’s election.
Culinary Conversation: My, oh my, it’s pie!
Making a pie crust can result in one of two things. You’ll either be remembered as the king or queen every time the word pastry is mentioned. Or you won’t. For some, that age-old cliché “easy as pie” is not that simple.
Mitchel Olszak: Autumn becomes the time to report for leaf duty
This time of year, I find myself frequently looking skyward. I’m not pondering the clouds, anticipating snow or scanning for NSA drones. Rather, I’m looking at the trees.
Culinary Conversation: Time to plan Thanksgiving meal
The calendar doesn’t lie. Thanksgiving is less than three weeks away. Then planning begins for all the other holiday meals. I have already made up a list of what we’re making on Christmas Eve and Christmas Day. It’s a frenzy of preparation and two days of baking and cooking, but I wouldn’t change any of it for the world.
John K. Manna: Taking a look at Tuesday’s election results
What to take away from Tuesday’s election in Lawrence County. Maybe not much, but let’s try. Voter turnout was awful — just below 20 percent. Based on records of the county Board of Elections, it was the worst turnout for a general election within the last 30 years.
John K. Manna: Voters must make choices in ‘off-year’ contests
I don’t know who coined the phrase “off-year election.” The implication is that it’s not as important as presidential, gubernatorial and congressional elections.
Culinary Conversation: Tasty dishes fit for a restaurant buffet
My first recollection of visiting a buffet restaurant was for my grandparents’ 50th wedding anniversary. That was a long time ago, and I don’t remember much except that there was a large group of us and the restaurant was somewhere in Boardman.
- More Columns Headlines
- Mitchel Olszak: Personal skepticism is best defense against scams