In the debate over health care reform, he who yells loudest, wins.
At least that seems to be the mindset of people who are showing up across the country at assorted town hall meetings hosted by members of Congress. News reports — especially those on TV and others desperate for drama — show people literally getting in the faces of politicians and screaming at the top of their lungs.
What are they screaming about? Well, the specific words vary, but most are upset with government in general and proposals for health care reform in particular.
Mixed in are the emotions of folks who obviously were on the losing side of the last election. You hear talk about the need to get their country back, while they compare current political trends in Washington to either Nazi Germany or Soviet Russia.
For consistency’s sake, I wish they would pick one or the other.
What’s happening with health care reform hardly reflects either of these totalitarian models. Rather, we are still in the relatively early stages of a legislative process where assorted powerful special interests have a great deal of money at stake.
And we shouldn’t be surprised that those interests want to protect their turf by muddying the political waters.
When Washington shows little or no interest in health care reform, the American people are up in arms over it. They object to the costs, the bureaucracy, the confusion and the insensitivity.
But now that politicians are responding to public demands, there’s suddenly a growing outcry from those who don’t want to put their health and their lives in the hands of the federal government.
Apparently, they’re much more comfortable with the decisions of life and death made by insurance companies.
I’ll be the first to admit that any time Washington seeks to develop major new initiatives, it’s a cause for concern. The rules and regulations drafted in the rarefied air of the nation’s capital don’t always translate well down in the lower atmosphere.
So I have no objection to the Americans asking their representatives tough, pointed questions. They should.
But these same people also need to understand the legislative process. Even though something’s being discussed, it’s still a long way from becoming law.
Most legislative proposals in Washington, Harrisburg and elsewhere never see the light of day. Exploring and examining new ideas — and putting them up for public review — is an essential role in a healthy open society.
Trying to shout ideas down without serious examination is not part of that healthy society. Instead, it’s a symptom of a populace that’s allowing itself to be duped by fear. It’s OK to be suspicious of health care reform, just so long as you’re also suspicious of special interests with huge financial stakes in protecting the status quo.
Consider claims we’ve been hearing about federal “death panels.” Critics of health reform — among them former Alaska Gov. Sarah Palin — have attempted to argue proposed legislation would establish boards whose members would assess the seriously ill and elderly, to decide who would live and who would die.
There are, of course, no such panels in any legislation being considered. But Palin’s defenders say that data collection and efforts at cost control sought in new legislation could one day pave the way for these death panels.
But that’s like saying theoretically, I could choke to death while eating my next meal. Therefore, I should never eat again.
I would like to think our society is guided by better logic than this. But the battle over health reform makes me wonder.
Columns
Related Photos
Discussion
DEAR READER: Health care debate is loud and ludicrous
- Columns
-
-
Lori Brothers: Get connected for better health
I am always happy when I see the lifesaving value of connection happening around me. It makes my heart smile when many people spontaneously unite. There is a feeling of excitement and community. Everyone gets onto the same page, when often the pages are scattered.
-
Mitchel Olszak: Scammers learn to feed off human fear
A few weeks ago, my computer went crazy. Boxes filled with warning notices and ominous-looking yellow triangles popped up on my screen, to tell me my system was filled with dangerous viruses. I was in imminent danger of having all sorts of personal information, passwords and financial data stolen.
-
John K. Manna: State Supreme Court explains fault with redistricting plan
A couple of things: We finally have an opinion. A week after it threw out a redistricting plan for state legislative districts, the Pennsylvania Supreme Court released its opinion yesterday.
-
Dave Ramsey: Proper insurance can transfer risk
“Dave Says" is a weekly column featuring financial advice from nationally syndicated radio host Dave Ramsey. His column is filled with timely, relevant questions and answers taken from actual letters and calls on Ramsey's radio program, “The Dave Ramsey Show.”
-
Lori Brothers: Organic is good, but it’s not always necessary
How often do you have a great conversation with your produce man? I encourage it. I got quite an explanation about how organic veggies are handled. I also found out there are certain guidelines about where they can even be located to be sold as “organic.”
-
Mitchel Olszak: Does making the press the villain play over time?
As a journalist and editor, I receive a lot of requests for help. They come from people suffering from injustice — real or perceived. They come from people who are struggling to grasp the finer points of modern bureaucracy.
-
Dave Ramsey: What’s your emergency fund range?
“Dave Says" is a weekly column featuring financial advice from nationally syndicated radio host Dave Ramsey. His column is filled with timely, relevant questions and answers taken from actual letters and calls on Ramsey's radio program, “The Dave Ramsey Show.”
-
Culinary Conversation: It’s time to get your orange on
Life is about routines. Get up, shower, have coffee, get dressed and go to work. Most of us probably eat the same type of breakfast every day. Some skip it all together.
-
Lori Brothers: Fleshing out ideas for skin care
It does appear that winter has finally parked over our little neck of the woods. It is the time of year when hands and lips get dry and chapped. Also, since we don’t get enough sun, we start looking a little pale. So what can we do for our skin?
-
Mitchel Olszak: Is county ready for change in government?
In Voltaire’s classic story “Candide,” the character Pangloss makes a frequent observation: “This is,” he says, “the best of all possible worlds.” Everything is wonderful, so why attempt to make things better?
- More Columns Headlines
-
