New Castle News

All About You ...

August 19, 2013

Mitchel Olszak: NSA defenders miss bigger picture

NEW CASTLE — The political establishment in Washington has circled the wagons around the National Security Agency.

This is the intelligence organization tasked with a key aspect of national defense: Monitoring potential threats and gathering information designed to protect America and its interests.

But recent revelations have shown the NSA operating within a wider scope than had been revealed. Basically, the agency is collecting vast amounts of data on Americans regarding phone records and Internet use.

It has privacy advocates upset and politicians making excuses.

We have been repeatedly assured — by leaders of both parties — that citizens’ privacy is not being violated, and that the NSA is simply doing its job to protect us.

For instance, appearing on CBS News’ “Face the Nation” program Aug. 11, Rep. Peter King, a New York Republican who’s toying with running for president, groused that President Obama isn’t doing enough to defend the agency — even though the president has been doing plenty of that.

According to King, “These people in the NSA are patriots. It’s probably what’s annoyed me the most over the last several months is people casually using words like ‘spying,’ ‘snooping.’

“I think that has really demeaned the whole political dialogue and that’s why I wish the president (would) be more outgoing before this war and defended the NSA a lot more than he did because this has really been a slander on the thousands of good men and women who every day dedicate their lives for our country.”

Well, I am sure these people are patriots. But so am I. And like any good American, I am innately suspicious of concentrations of too much power. That includes the NSA.

And despite all the protestations from Obama, King and other politicians, The Washington Post reported last week that a leaked audit showed the NSA broke privacy rules it was supposed to follow thousands of times. That doesn’t sound like the crackerjack, professional operation that’s been presented to the public by NSA defenders.

Yes, these NSA operatives may be patriots. But they are also bureaucrats and human beings. In many ways they are the same sort of federal bureaucrats that people like King routinely bash when they work in other areas of government.

It’s human nature to want to find ways to cut corners in how we do things. Our rationales may not be evil and in many cases may be absolutely harmless.

But when it comes to basic privacy rights, cutting corners and making mistakes cause problems. Combine that with the fact human nature also means that people are not always honorable and ethical in what they do, and the NSA program presents multiple concerns.

To put it simply, we don’t know what has happened within the NSA and how far it has gone, because its operations are so secretive. And contrary to any claims from its apologists in Washington, oversight is horrible.

The court that authorizes NSA activities receives its information only from the agency. There are no meaningful safeguards or means of questioning its actions.

Congressional committees supposedly get reports of what the NSA is doing, but these are only as good as the material provided. If the NSA fails to be forthcoming, or ignores requests for information (as reportedly happens) how does that constitute effective monitoring by the legislative branch?

America needs to defend itself from terror threats. But it also needs to defend itself from excessive, secretive and unaccountable government agencies. There’s work to do here.

Text Only | Photo Reprints
All About You ...
  • stright.jpg Sarah Stright-Hartley: These pastels will put a spring in your step

    Is it just me or are pastels ubiquitous with spring? Once the season hits, they're everywhere. It's taken me awhile to jump on the pastel bandwagon and even still I can't wear them head to toe like some women do.

    April 23, 2014 3 Photos

  • Kali.jpg Kali Davies-Anderson: Experiment proves cake really is a slice of heaven

    There are few things on this earth and beyond that I love more than cake.  I love my family, I love my friends, I love Jesus, and I love cake — and not necessarily in that order (sorry, family).

    April 22, 2014 1 Photo

  • peaches.tiff Your Summer Treats: Poor peach crop expected

    Local peaches may be scarce in Lawrence County this summer. County fruit farmers are watching their peach trees closely, not sure how badly they were damaged by the winter’s extreme cold.

    April 21, 2014 1 Photo

  • Hudson.jpg Culinary Conversation: Think globally, cook locally

    Another set of bookshelves might be necessary at my house very soon. It’s been a bountiful week. Edie Majesky of New Castle, who I have known most of my life, is aware of how much I love collecting old cookbooks.

    April 19, 2014 1 Photo

  • Ramsey.jpg Dave Says: Problems with no credit score?

    “Dave Says” is a weekly column featuring financial advice from nationally syndicated radio host Dave Ramsey. His column is filled with timely, relevant questions and answers taken from actual letters and calls on Ramsey’s radio progam, “The Dave Ramsey Show.”

    April 18, 2014 1 Photo

  • Brothers.jpg Lori Brothers: Play with names — not with your food

    Do you remember being told, “don’t play with your food” when you were a child?  Or maybe you’ve said this to your own children or grandchildren. I’ve heard stories about kids slipping food under the table to the dog or stuffing Brussels sprouts into their pockets to get out of the pain of eating them.

    April 17, 2014 1 Photo

  • stright.jpg Sarah Stright-Hartley: A T-shirt dress can be a three for all

    I love finding pieces that can be worn for just about every portion of my life.  From daytime, to work, and then on a date with my husband, I like pieces that can go the distance.

    April 16, 2014 2 Photos

  • ivy_bday.jpg Kali Davies-Anderson: Happy birthday, Miss Ivy!

    This week I would like to take time out of my usual ramblings to wish my second born daughter, Ivy, a very, very happy first birthday!

    April 15, 2014 2 Photos

  • Olszak.jpg Heartbleed raises the stakes on Internet security

    My column last week dealt with Internet and related scams, along with steps people can take to protect themselves. Today’s column could be termed Part 2 of that topic, albeit from a different angle.

    April 14, 2014 1 Photo

  • Hudson.jpg Lugene Hudson: Celebrate Easter like Helen Martin

    What’s cookin? That’s one of our favorite questions at Culinary Conversation. We love when readers share some of their favorites. This week, Helen Martin of New Castle stepped up to the plate to answer that question regarding Easter dinners.

    April 12, 2014 1 Photo

House Ads

Milwaukee catcher Martin Maldonado has been suspended five games for sucker punching Pittsburgh’s Travis Snider during a bench clearing brawl on Sunday. You OK with that suspension?

Yes. Seems fair.
No. Baseball NEVER gets it right in these situations. Should have been at least 20 games for his sucker punch into a pile of players.
Not sure, but I’d love to see baseball be like hockey and allow two guys to fight for a while before breaking it up. Let’s see how tough Maldonado is then.
     View Results